Which would you rather have?

Honestly I think you would be down grading in this trade by a pretty good amount. Cabrera is yes by far the best player in the deal, but Tulo hasn't done anything this year even though he is on the DL. You know what you will get with the 3 you would be trading, but for the players you get you know what Miggy will get you but it is still Tulo's 2nd year playing really so you can't really predict what he will get. If you could I would try choosing a different player than Tulo.